Abstract
Effective management of a socio-ecological system (SES) requires a good understanding of: (i) ecosystem functionality, (ii) interactions between social and ecological units, and (iii) stakeholder perceptions and activities. Matang Mangrove Forest Reserve (MMFR) covering 40,200 ha in Peninsular Malaysia is under silvicultural management (with a 30-year forest rotation cycle) for charcoal and timber production since 1902. The aim of this study is to assess the perceptions of (select) local stakeholders on the ongoing mangrove management of MMFR. Earlier, Huge et al. (2016), using Q methodology, identified three main shared perceptions, called discourses: (1) Optimization- ‘keep up the good work, but keep improving’, (2) Change for the better- ‘ecotourism & participatory management for sustainability’, and (3) Continuity – ‘business as usual is the way to go’. The current study is a follow-up to Huge et al. (2016) and reports on a survey which assessed the degree of support of the local stakeholders towards those three management discourses. The core statements of each discourse were presented as questions and then ranked by the participants. Based on the findings of the survey, the local stakeholders were clustered into three main working categories: (i) charcoal and timber workers, (ii) fishermen and (iii) service providers. The interviews held with 114 stakeholders indicated that discourse (2) ‘change for the better’ is the most popular (supported by 72% of the participants) regardless of the stakeholders’ working category. This discourse voices the involvement of local people in decision making, adopts participatory management, and encourages diverse mangrove-based economic activities beyond mere charcoal and timber production. Single-use management (focusing only on maximising charcoal and timber yields) was perceived as not equitably benefiting all local stakeholders. The insights of this study can guide the managers of Matang Mangrove Forest Reserve to improve the sustainability and the local support base for the existing mangrove management regime, e.g. by promoting diverse livelihood options for the local stakeholders.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Article number | 117741 |
| Journal | Forest Ecology and Management |
| Volume | 458 |
| DOIs | |
| Publication status | Published - 15 Feb 2020 |
Bibliographical note
Funding Information:We would like to thank Nur Syahirah Mohd Radzi and Lee Soon Siong and Chua Yee Ling for their field assistance and language translation Malay-English and Chinese-English during the fieldwork. We thank the Forestry Department Malaysia and State Forestry Department of Perak for granting their permission to work at Kuala Sepetang. We thank Kuala Sepetang's community for participating in this survey and Mr. Kamal's family who provided us local hospitality. Terima kasih atas sambutan yang mesra, 感谢你热情的欢迎. We acknowledge the Matang Mangrove Forest Reserve ranger team, in particular, ranger Pak Abu for the logistic support provided. We thank Beth Turner and Lucy Van Dieijen for proofreading and Juan Luis Lechuga Crespo, for his ideas concerning data treatment. An Erasmus Mundus TROPIMUNDO MSc thesis scholarship provided the financial needs to complete the present study.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2019 Elsevier B.V.
Copyright:
Copyright 2019 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.
Keywords
- Mangrove management
- Local-population perception
- Stakeholder involvement
- Forest management
- Socio-ecological system
- Ecosystem services